Vantage vs M1 Finance

Vantage vs M1 Finance Comparison Table 2024
Vantage M1 Finance
4.7
3.9

M1 Finance is #16 in our broker rankings.

United States Flag Traders from US not accepted
United States Flag Traders from US accepted

Founded in 2009, Vantage offers trading on 1000+ short-term CFD products to over 900,000 clients. You can trade Forex CFDs from 0.0 pips on the RAW account through TradingView, MT4 or MT5. Vantage is ASIC-regulated and client funds are segregated. Copy traders will also appreciate the range of social trading tools.

M1 Finance is a US brokerage that allows users to build a customizable investment portfolio from a range of 6000+ stocks and shares, ETFs and cryptocurrencies. The innovative 'pie' based portfolio management system allows traders to build several portfolios with different aims, and the brokerage supports machine-learning tools that can provide automated portfolio management.

Customer Reviews
4.3
Bonus Offer
50% Welcome Deposit Bonus, earn redeemable rewards in the Vantage Rewards scheme M1 Finance Plus free for 3 months on new accounts
Comment by Reviewer
"Vantage remains an excellent option for CFD traders seeking a tightly-regulated broker with access to the reliable MetaTrader platforms. The fast sign-up process and $50 minimum deposit make it very straightforward to start day trading quickly." "M1 Finance remains a great choice for US investors who want a straightforward, commission-free way to invest in stocks and crypto. The intuitive dashboard, customizable portfolios and fractional shares should appeal to all experience levels and investing goals. "
Pros
  • Vantage maintains its high trust score thanks to its strong reputation and top-tier regulation from the FCA and ASIC
  • The ECN accounts are very competitive with spreads from 0.0 pips and a $1.50 commission per side
  • There’s an excellent suite of day trading software, including the award-winning platforms MT4 and MT5
  • The broker has recently made efforts to expand its suite of CFDs providing further trading opportunities
  • Vantage caters to hands-off investors with beginner-friendly social trading via ZuluTrade & Myfxbook
  • The low minimum deposit of $50 and zero funding fees make this broker a great choice for new traders
  • There are no short-term strategy restrictions with hedging and scalping permitted
  • It’s quick and easy to open a live account – taking less than 2 minutes
  • Thanks to additional extras like a bank account and loan service, M1 Finance continues to offer a one-stop shop for investors
  • The broker offers commission-free stocks with low fees, plus fractional shares, making it a great choice for beginners
  • The broker delivers a clean and easy-to-use dashboard that illustrates the current composition of your portfolio
  • The firm offers a straightforward proprietary platform with intuitive portfolio management tools
  • Multiple portfolios can be facilitated, with up to five accounts under the same login
  • Customizable 'pies' allow investors to curate their own ETFs
  • The range of 6000+ stocks and ETFs is highly competitive
  • Bitcoin trading is available through M1 Crypto
Cons
  • It's a shame that some clients will need to register with the offshore entity, which offers less regulatory protection
  • A steep $10,000 deposit is needed for the best trading conditions, which include the $1.50 commission per side
  • The average execution speeds of 100ms to 250ms are slower than alternatives based on tests
  • Unfortunately, cryptos are only available for Australian clients
  • Despite offering stocks and ETFs, M1 Finance doesn’t provide trading on mutual funds or options
  • Unlike competitors such as Betterment, M1 does not employ any human financial advisors
  • M1 Finance is only available in the US – eToro is a top alternative for the UK market
  • Accounts with less than $20 and no trading activity for 90 days are charged a fee
  • The way trades are placed puts transaction timing out of your control
  • You cannot consolidate external accounts for planning purposes
  • There are no stop-limit or stop-loss orders
Awards
  • Best Broker Australia - Ultimate Fintech Awards 2022
  • Best In CFD Trading 2022 - The European Global Banking & Finance Awards 2022
  • Best Trading App - Professional Trader Awards 2022
  • Best Trade Execution - Global Forex Awards 2023
  • Best Roth IRA Accounts - 2020
Instruments
CFDs, Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, ETFs, Bonds Stocks, ETFs, OTC stocks
Demo Account
Yes Yes
Minimum Deposit
$50 $100
Trading Platforms
  • ProTrader
  • MT4
  • MT5
  • TradingView
  • DupliTrade
  • Own
Payment Methods
Minimum Trade
0.01 Lots $1
Regulator
FCA, ASIC, FSCA, VFSC SEC, FINRA
Margin Trading
Yes Yes
Margin Rate
3.5 - 5%
STP Account
Yes No
ECN Account
Yes No
DMA Account
No No
MAM Account
Yes No
PAMM Account
Yes No
LAMM Account
No No
Demat Account
No No
AI / Machine Learning
No Yes
Robo Advisor
No Yes
Negative Balance Protection
Yes No
Market Maker
No No
P2P Trading
No No
Spot Trading
Yes Yes
Mobile Apps
iOS & Android Yes
App Review

Vantage offers one of the most complete trading apps we’ve used. The crisp design and slick interface makes analyzing markets and placing trades straightforward. Changing to horizontal mode offers an optimal charting view, though frustratingly it can take a few seconds for the app to respond. Fortunately, this minor drawback is outweighed by the ease of overlaying indicators and drawing tools, plus the integrated economic calendar, newsfeed, market analysis, and even FX TV.

Android App Rating
3.9
iOS App Rating
3.6
Auto Trading
Myfxbook AutoTrade, Expert Advisors (EAs) on MetaTrader Yes
Copy Trading
Yes No
Copy Trading Platform
Traders enjoy social and copy trading at Vantage with the MetaTrader packages, DupliTrade, ZuluTrade and Myfxbook. ZuluTrade is one of the best social trading communities, using a sophisticated algorithm to rank top signal providers.
Social Trading
Yes No
Trade Signals
Yes
VPS Hosting
Yes No
Tournaments
No No
Demo Competitions
Yes No
Ethical Investing
No Yes
Custodial Account
No Yes
Guaranteed Stop Loss
No No
Inactivity Fee
$0 $20
Islamic Account
Yes No
Account Currencies
  • USD
  • EUR
  • GBP
  • CAD
  • AUD
  • NZD
  • JPY
  • HKD
  • SGD
  • PLN
  • USD
Stock Exchanges
Commodities
CFD Trading
Traders can speculate on 1000+ financial markets with high leverage up to 1:500. You can bet on rising and falling prices in currencies, commodities, indices, shares, and more without owning the underlying asset. With the comprehensive choice of CFD trading platforms, users can also switch between desktop, web and mobile for a seamless trading experience. CFD trading not offered
Leverage
1:500
FTSE Spread
1.0
GBPUSD Spread
0.5
Oil Spread
0.01
Stocks Spread
0.01 $0
Forex Trading
Vantage offers 55+ currency pairs - above the industry average, so experienced traders can explore plenty of opportunities. Vantage's deep liquidity pool provides forex spreads from 0.0 pips in the ECN account, lower than many alternatives. There are also no commissions, deposit fees or hidden charges. Forex trading not offered
GBPUSD Spread
0.5
EURUSD Spread
0.0
EURGBP Spread
0.5
Assets
55+
Currency Indices
  • USD
Cryptocurrency
You can trade cryptos 24/7, including Bitcoin, with up to 1:200 leverage and zero overnight fees. Various risk management tools are also available, including price alerts and stop losses. The Vantage app also offers an excellent live news feed so you can keep track of the crypto market whilst on the go. M1 Finance users can open a crypto account to invest in 10 cryptocurrencies including Bitcoin, Ethereum, Cardano and Solana. You can also invest in six crypto-related funds and ETFs, which are a good way to get broader exposure to the digital currency market.
Spread
Floating Variable
Coins
  • ADA
  • AVA
  • BTC
  • DOG
  • EOS
  • ETH
  • LTC
  • NEO
  • SHB
  • SOL
  • TRX
  • UNI
  • XRPandmanymore
  • BTC
  • ADA
  • AVE
  • ETH
  • LINK
  • ALDO
  • BAT
  • ATOM
Crypto Lending
No No
Crypto Mining
No No
Crypto Staking
No No
Auto Market Maker
No No
More Comparisons
Vantage
vs
M1 Finance
vs