Hedge Fund vs. Mutual Fund
A hedge fund and mutual fund are both types of investment vehicles that provide a way for individuals to invest their money.
However, they each have different goals, strategies, and management structures which makes them appealing to different types of investors.
Hedge Fund vs. Mutual Fund – Key Takeaways
- Hedge funds are typically only available to high-net-worth investors and institutions, while mutual funds are more widely accessible.
- Hedge funds aim to produce absolute returns, meaning they focus on achieving positive returns independent of the stock market’s performance. Mutual funds typically aim to outperform a benchmark index like the S&P 500 or Nasdaq Composite.
- Hedge fund fees tend to be higher than those associated with mutual funds due to their higher risk profile and active management strategies.
- Unlike hedge funds, mutual fund investments are highly regulated by the SEC, which ensures transparency and provides greater protection for investors.
Hedge funds
Hedge funds are typically the more aggressive option and are normally open only to accredited investors who must prove minimum income and net worth requirements.
Hedge fund managers will make use of financial tools such as short selling, leverage, derivatives, and other complex products in order to generate higher returns than what might be available through traditional investments.
Those that use hedge funds – e.g., accredited investors, pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, endowments, foundations – often use them to get access to strategies that have lower correlations to traditional investments.
Such strategies could include things like distressed investing and special situations.
They also come with higher fees due to the active management style employed by hedge fund managers.
Hedge funds may charge anywhere from 1-3 percent management fees and anywhere from 10-45 percent of profits.
The better the track record, the higher the demand for the product, and the more active the management style, generally the higher the fees will tend to be.
Some hedge funds also run semi-passive products (e.g., risk parity) that will tend to charge modest management fees (0.5-1.0 percent) and often no or low performance fees.
Related
Mutual funds
Mutual funds, on the other hand, are open to virtually any investor and generally have low minimums for entry into the fund.
They tend to be more conservative than hedge funds, but also offer a way for investors to diversify their portfolio in order to spread out risk over different asset classes such as stocks, bonds, and real estate.
Mutual funds are long-only vehicles, so they will always tend to have some correlation to traditional investments.
Mutual funds are run by experienced professionals who look at the performance of individual investments and move money around in order to maximize returns while minimizing risk.
They also offer the benefit of being more liquid since shares can be easily bought and sold on the open market.
What is the difference between a hedge fund and a mutual fund?
A hedge fund is an alternative investment vehicle that is typically structured as a private limited partnership.
Hedge funds often employ complex strategies such as leveraging debt, short-selling, arbitrage, derivatives trading, and other less common tactics to generate returns for their investors.
These high-risk strategies involve a great deal of risk management and the use sophisticated investments tools.
In comparison, mutual funds are open-ended investment vehicles that pool money from multiple investors and invest in stocks, bonds, or other securities.
Mutual funds offer relatively lower levels of risk but also lower potential returns.
While mutual funds can be actively managed by professionals who chose which investments to make, they are also subject to market risk and the general volatility of financial markets.
They are also long-only vehicles, so if what they invest in does poorly, then investors will lose money on a mark-to-market basis.
In addition, mutual funds have a predetermined set of regulations that dictate how they can invest their assets. Hedge funds tend to be more flexible in this regard.
Overall, hedge funds offer greater potential returns but at potentially higher level of risk than mutual funds. Investors should carefully consider their personal objectives and risk tolerance before investing in either type of fund.
Hedge funds vs. Mutual Funds – Absolute Returns vs. Relative Returns
Hedge funds and mutual funds both seek to produce returns on investments.
However, there are differences in the way they invest, with each having different types of return goals.
When looking at hedge funds vs. mutual funds, it is important to understand the difference between absolute returns and relative returns.
Absolute return measures investment performance against a benchmark index or fixed income rate. Relative return measures the performance of an investment compared to similar investments within its asset class or peer group.
Hedge funds typically focus on absolute returns where their goal is to provide investors with returns that get whatever is reasonable.
Hedge funds generally focus on capital appreciation and seek to generate absolute returns by investing in securities across multiple asset classes, employing leverage, and other strategies such as shorting stocks and other liquid securities and instruments.
Mutual funds, on the other hand, typically focus on relative returns where their goal is to outperform a benchmark or peer group over time.
Mutual funds are limited in their investment approach as they must follow certain regulations and cannot employ some of the more complicated strategies that hedge funds can. They focus primarily on long-term growth through stock selection rather than relying heavily on leverage or derivatives.
When comparing hedge funds vs. mutual funds, it is important to understand the difference between absolute return goals and relative return goals.
For investors seeking higher potential returns with higher risk/reward ratios, hedge funds may be a better option. For investors seeking more conservative strategies with lower risk/reward ratios, mutual funds are typically a better choice.
It is also important to understand that regardless of the type of fund chosen, all investments involve some degree of risk and it is important to do your research before committing any capital.
With the right approach and understanding, both hedge funds and mutual funds can be effective tools for generating returns on investments.
Related: Hedge Funds Don’t Beat The Market – Is This a Bad Thing?
Why are hedge funds better than mutual funds?
Neither is inherently better, as both offer distinct advantages and disadvantages.
Hedge funds may provide investors with more potential returns due to their aggressive strategies, while mutual funds offer lower levels of risk and less stringent regulations.
Hedge funds are less liquid and have higher capital requirements, while mutual funds are more liquid and have lower capital requirements.
The type of fund that is best for a given investor depends upon the individual’s risk tolerance and financial goals. Investors should carefully consider these factors when deciding between hedge funds or mutual funds when faced with the choice.
What are some risks associated with investing in a hedge fund?
Some common risks associated with hedge funds include:
- leverage-induced losses
- liquidity issues
- lack of transparency
- management fees, and
- conflicts of interest
Leverage-induced losses can occur if the investments do not perform as expected or substantially decline in value.
Liquidity issues are due to the fact that hedge funds cannot be easily sold on the open market. They have lock-up periods and it’s common for investors to only be able to exit quarterly and often only a fraction of the funds they have committed. These rules are in place so it doesn’t interfere with a manager’s strategy.
In addition, some hedge funds do not provide sufficient disclosure on their trading strategies or positions and this lack of transparency can be risky. This is done to avoid disadvantaging their clients.
Management fees are another risk factor to consider as they can significantly reduce investor returns.
Finally, conflicts of interest may arise if managers prioritize their own interests over those of the investors.
Is a hedge fund a type of mutual fund?
No, a hedge fund is not a type of mutual fund.
A mutual fund is an open-ended investment vehicle that pools money from multiple investors and invests in stocks, bonds, or other securities.
By contrast, a hedge fund is an alternative investment vehicle that employs complex strategies such as leverage, short-selling, arbitrage, derivatives, complex products, and other less traditional tactics to generate returns for their investors.
Overall, the two types of funds offer distinct advantages and disadvantages and should be carefully considered when making investment decisions.
FAQs – Hedge Fund vs. Mutual Fund
What is a hedge fund in simple terms?
In simple terms, a hedge fund is an alternative investment vehicle that uses complex strategies such as leveraging debt, being able to go short or long, engaging in various forms of arbitrage, trading derivatives, and other less common strategies to generate returns for the investors.
It’s more common for hedge funds to participate in liquid markets, but many own private assets as well.
Some buy controlling interests in businesses and manage them like regular business owners.
So, a hedge fund is basically a “just make money” type of vehicle, not something that only sticks to trading liquid markets.
What is a mutual fund in simple terms?
A mutual fund is an open-ended investment vehicle that pools money from multiple investors and invests in stocks, bonds, or other securities.
It offers investors the opportunity to diversify their investments by investing in a mix of different assets.
Are hedge funds riskier than mutual funds?
Hedge funds tend to be riskier than mutual funds due to their aggressive strategies which offer higher potential returns but also higher levels of risk.
Investors should carefully consider their own goals and risk tolerance before investing in a hedge fund.
Are hedge funds more profitable than mutual funds?
It depends on the individual investments and strategies chosen by each fund manager, but generally speaking, hedge funds tend to be more profitable than mutual funds due to their higher levels of risk.
However, this increased potential for return comes with an increased level of risk.
Are there any restrictions on who can invest in a hedge fund?
Yes, most hedge funds impose certain restrictions on who can invest.
Generally speaking, only accredited investors with high net worths or sophisticated investors (e.g., institutions) are allowed to invest in a hedge fund.
Additionally, hedge funds typically require a minimum investment amount, so investors should be aware of any restrictions before investing in a hedge fund.
Some hedge funds have minimums as high as $50-$100 million. They may also require their investors to have a certain amount of assets under management. This figure can be over $5 billion in required AUM to get into some hedge funds.
Are there any tax implications when investing in a hedge fund?
Yes, the taxes on profits from investments made in a hedge fund may vary depending on the specific laws and regulations of the country or jurisdiction where you are located.
It is important to consult with a financial advisor or tax specialist to understand what taxes and fees might apply.
What type of returns can I expect from my investments in a hedge fund?
Returns from investments made in a hedge fund will depend on the strategies used by the individual portfolio manager as well as the overall performance of the fund.
As a general guide, hedge funds typically have higher expected returns than mutual funds (but also higher risk) and may deliver returns in excess of 10 percent over time if allowed to take enough risk.
However, past performance is not indicative of future results. Additionally, all investments involve some degree of risk and there are no guarantees or assurances that any returns will be achieved.
Conclusion – Hedge Fund vs. Mutual Fund
Overall, both hedge funds and mutual funds offer investors a way to grow their wealth. Which one is right for you depends largely on your risk tolerance and financial goals.
Hedge funds may provide higher returns but come with greater risks while mutual funds are less risky on average but tend to produce lower returns.