Which broker has the most profitable traders? Or as some like to put it – which brokers have the fewest losing traders? This is a question that most traders think about and yet seems unanswerable… How and why would brokers reveal this information?
Thanks to the ESMA (European Securities and Markets Authority), brokers are now bound to disclose their percentage of winning/losing traders. This increased transparency has the potential to disrupt the market for binary options, CFDs and forex. This article will explore these revelations and assess their impact on the future of retail trading.
Brokers With Most Winning Traders
These are the top 6 brokers with the most winning traders, and what percentage of their traders are profitable:
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: CySEC
- Min. deposit: $100
49% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. -
- Demo account
- Min. deposit: $10 (varies by account and payment method)
- Min. trade: 0.01 Lots
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: FCA, CySEC, FC
- Platforms: TickTrader, MT4, MT5, TradingView
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: FCA, ASIC, JSC, FSC, VFSC, FSA
- Platforms: MT4, MT5, TradingCentral
-
- Demo account
- Instruments: CFDs, Forex, Indices, Shares, Commodities
- Regulator: ASIC, CySEC, FSCA, FSC
-
- Demo account
- Platforms: xStation
- Min. deposit: $0
69-80% of accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.
Learn how we test brokers and why you can trust our ratings.
Here is a short overview of each broker's pros and cons
- Skilling 3.4/5 Skilling is a multi-asset broker founded in 2016 and based in Cyprus. The brand offers hundreds of day trading instruments with competitive spreads from 0.1 pips and beginner-friendly platforms. Skilling are also regulated in Europe and beyond with a transparent pricing structure. You can sign up and start trading in three easy steps.
- Exness 4.1/5 Established in 2008, Exness has maintained its position as a highly respected broker, standing out with its industry-leading range of 40+ account currencies, growing selection of CFD instruments, and intuitive web platform complete with useful extras like currency convertors and trading calculators.
- FXOpen 3.7/5 Established in 2005, FXOpen is a multi-regulated broker that has attracted over 1 million traders. Designed for active trading, it provides access to a growing selection of more than 700 markets and supports high-frequency trading, scalping, and all forms of algorithmic trading using expert advisors (EAs).
- Hantec Markets 3.8/5 Hantec Markets was established in Hong Kong in 1990. Initially, the company concentrated solely on the Chinese and Taiwanese markets. In 2008, the broker rebranded and expanded its presence in the UK, Australia, Japan, and various other countries, before enhancing its footprint in Latin America in 2022. Hantec now stands as a multinational brokerage with 18 offices across Europe and Asia.
- FBS 4.3/5 Founded in 2009, FBS is an award-winning CFD broker operating in over 150 countries with a client base exceeding 27 million traders. Traders are supported at every stage of their journey with 24/7 assistance, market analytics, trading calculators, and competitive pricing with zero commissions.
- XTB 4.8/5 Founded in 2002 in Poland, XTB now serves more than 1 million clients. The forex and CFD broker combines a heavily regulated trading environment with an extensive selection of assets and a commitment to trader satisfaction, featuring an intuitive in-house platform with superb tools to support aspiring day traders.
Community Sentiment
See how users rate these brokers based on the average customer ratings submitted on DayTrading.com, plus ratings from Trustpilot, the Apple App Store and Google Play.
| Broker | Our Users' Rating | Trustpilot Score | Trustpilot Reviews | iOS App Rating | Android App Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Skilling | 446 | ||||
| Exness | 33680 | ||||
| FXOpen | 462 | ||||
| Hantec Markets | 5642 | ||||
| FBS | 10221 | ||||
| XTB | 3010 |
Skilling
Skilling maintains its position as a top pick for budding traders looking for a competitive zero commission account with direct access to a copy trading feature. It will also serve experienced strategy providers looking to earn commissions, or active traders looking to deal forex.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
Skilling quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- Forex, CFDs, Stocks, Indices, Commodities and Cryptos
- Regulator
- CySEC
- Platforms
- Skilling Trader, MT4, MT5, cTrader, TradingView
- Minimum Deposit
- $100
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, SEK, NOK
Skilling Profitable Traders
Pros
- Skilling offers five trading platforms: Skilling Trader, cTrader, MT4, MT5, and TradingView, each with distinct strengths. MT4 and MT5 supports EA-based strategies, cTrader excels in order management, Skilling Trader offers straightforward web execution, and TradingView specializes in advanced charting. This range provides valuable flexibility for traders
- The Skilling Trader platform maintains a focused design, offering charts, order placement, and risk controls without unnecessary features or promotional content. For systematic traders or those who prefer a streamlined execution environment, this simplicity is an advantage
- Beyond major forex pairs, Skilling’s spreads are often lower than those of larger, more prominent brokers. While not always the lowest, traders focused on raw pricing can find competitive value without needing a full ECN setup
Cons
- Skilling’s educational and research resources are limited to a basic economic calendar, brief market commentary, some lessons, and occasional news headlines, plus the newer AI-powered Skilling Trade Assistant. There aren't comprehensive and structured learning paths
- Skilling depends on TradingView for advanced analytics and does not provide its own platform for Trading Central, Autochartist, or instrument-specific news feeds. This may be sufficient for traders with independent research tools, but it is less comprehensive than brokers offering integrated in-platform content
Exness
After slashing its spreads, improving its execution speeds and support trading on over 100 currency pairs with more than 40 account currencies to choose from, Exness is a fantastic option for active forex traders looking to minimize trading costs.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
Exness quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs on Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, Crypto
- Regulator
- FSCA, CMA-Kenya, FSA, CBCS, BVIFSC, FSC, JSC, FCA (B2B only), CySEC (B2B only)
- Platforms
- Exness Trade App, Exness Terminal, MT4, MT5, TradingCentral
- Minimum Deposit
- $10 (varies by account and payment method)
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, NZD, INR, JPY, ZAR, MYR, IDR, CHF, HKD, SGD, AED, SAR, HUF, BRL, NGN, THB, VND, UAH, KWD, QAR, KRW, MXN, KES, CNY
Exness Profitable Traders
Pros
- Fast and dependable 24/7 multilingual customer support via telephone, email and live chat based on hands-on tests.
- Highly competitive spreads, reduced for USOIL and BTCUSD in 2024, are available from 0 pips with low commissions from $2 per side.
- Charting tools have been improved through Indie - traders can write Python scripts and add custom indicators to charts in the Exness Terminal and MT5, as well as testing them against market data.
Cons
- MetaTrader 4 and 5 are supported, but TradingView and cTrader still aren’t despite rising demand from active traders and integration at alternatives like Pepperstone.
- Retail trading services are unavailable in certain jurisdictions, such as the US, UK, EU, and more recently India, limiting accessibility compared to top-tier brokers like Interactive Brokers.
- Exness has expanded its range of CFDs, but there are still no real assets such as ETFs, cryptocurrencies or bonds
FXOpen
FXOpen is ideal for high-volume traders, offering fast execution through its ECN trading infrastructure, spreads from 0 pips, and discounted commissions as low as $1.50 per lot.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
FXOpen quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs, Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, Crypto, ETFs
- Regulator
- FCA, CySEC, FC
- Platforms
- TickTrader, MT4, MT5, TradingView
- Minimum Deposit
- $100
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, AUD, JPY, CHF, SGD, RUB
FXOpen Profitable Traders
Pros
- FXOpen streamlined its account offerings in 2024, ensuring a user-friendly setup with ECN accounts providing raw spreads from 0.0 pips, fast execution speeds, and discounted commissions for high-volume traders.
- FXOpen reduced FX spreads by 40%+ in 2022 and introduced commission-free index trading in 2023, making it cost-effective for day traders.
- FXOpen introduced TradingView in 2022 and upgraded its TickTrader platform in 2024, offering Level 2 pricing, 1,200+ trading tools, and advanced order types, catering to both experienced and high-frequency traders.
Cons
- FXOpen has a threadbare educational offering, lacking the courses and webinars you can find at brokers like IG, limiting its appeal to beginners seeking to build their knowledge.
- While still a trusted broker with authorization from the FCA and CySEC, FXOpen lost its ASIC license in 2024 following ‘serious concerns’ and no longer onboards Australian traders.
- Despite bolstering its asset range, FXOpen still offers fewer global stocks, commodities, and cryptocurrencies than category leader BlackBull, reducing access to diverse trading opportunities.
Hantec Markets
Hantec Markets is suitable if you want a no-frills MetaTrader broker to trade CFDs on stocks, forex, indices, commodities and cryptos. However, the customer support and educational tools trail the best brokers.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
Hantec Markets quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- Forex, CFDs, Indices, Stocks, Commodities, Cryptos
- Regulator
- FCA, ASIC, JSC, FSC, VFSC, FSA
- Platforms
- MT4, MT5, TradingCentral
- Minimum Deposit
- $10
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, CHF, PLN, AED
Hantec Markets Profitable Traders
Pros
- Trading Central integration provides an excellent one-stop-shop for technical, fundamental, economic, sentiment and news analysis, helping users discover short-term trading opportunities.
- Hantec Markets offers a great range of 8 account base currencies, helping global traders avoid conversion fees while delivering a hassle-free day trading experience.
- Hantec Markets is a trusted broker, with a track record stretching back to 1990 and authorization from ‘green tier’ regulators, notably the ASIC.
Cons
- While Hantec Markets is regulated by the FCA it's no longer accepting retail clients via this entity - Brits may be onboarded through an offshore entity without FCA protections.
- Testing reveals hit-and-miss support, with 24/5 assistance but a live chat service that times out, making it unreliable for urgent trading issues.
- Hantec Markets needs to bolster its investment offering to match category leaders like Blackbull Markets, especially in its breadth of currency pairs and commodities.
FBS
FBS is an excellent choice for day traders at every level and budget, with just a $5 minimum deposit and intensive academy for aspiring traders alongside access to MT4 and MT5.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
FBS quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs, Forex, Indices, Shares, Commodities
- Regulator
- ASIC, CySEC, FSCA, FSC
- Platforms
- FBS App, MT4, MT5
- Minimum Deposit
- $5
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, AUD, JPY
FBS Profitable Traders
Pros
- FBS offers lightning-fast execution speeds from just 10 milliseconds, placing it among the industry leaders for highly active traders like scalpers who demand rapid order processing.
- The introduction of the FBI Assistant has given active traders useful, AI-powered intelligence to assess charts and patterns with potential trade ideas that can be executed in one click.
- FBS strikes the balance between robust features and ease of use, with a sign-up process taking <10 minutes, an intuitive app, advanced research through Market Analytics & more recently VIP Analytics, plus immersive education through the FBS Academy and Trader’s Blog.
Cons
- There are only four base currencies available - EUR, USD, AUD and JPY (region dependant) - which isn't practical for minimizing currency conversion fees for many global traders, and is especially striking given the broker’s user base spans over 150 nations.
- Despite enhancing the selection of currency pairs, now providing over 70, FBS still trails industry leaders like BlackBull Markets in its market offering with a particularly narrow selection of commodities and indices.
- Although the FBS app offers a terrific mobile trading experience for aspiring traders and MT4/MT5 cater to advanced traders, the absence of cTrader and TradingView, which are increasingly offered by alternatives like Pepperstone, will deter day traders familiar with these platforms.
XTB
XTB stands out as a top choice for new day traders with the terrific xStation platform, low trading costs, no minimum deposit, and excellent educational tools, many of which are seamlessly integrated into the platform.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
XTB quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs on shares, Indices, ETFs, Raw Materials, Forex currencies, cryptocurrencies, Real shares, Real ETFs
- Regulator
- FCA, CySEC, KNF, DFSA, FSC, SCA, CMF, Bappebti
- Platforms
- xStation
- Minimum Deposit
- $0
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP
XTB Profitable Traders
Pros
- XTB has improved its assets and markets offering further in 2026 with options trading in Spain and Germany, spot cryptos in some regions, and Investment Plans 2.0 with more pre-built plans covering sectors like Defence, a more intuitive interface, and greater flexibility to combine single stocks and ETFs into individual plans.
- With an excellent range of educational materials, including training videos and articles integrated into the platform, XTB supports traders at all levels.
- XTB has boosted its interest rate on uninvested balances and added zero-fee ISAs (On ETFs and real shares, or 0.2% with transactions over €100k) for UK clients with a huge range of markets available.
Cons
- XTB does not offer a raw spread account, which is becoming increasingly common among competitors like Pepperstone, and may disappoint day traders looking for the tightest spreads.
- Trading fees are competitive with average spreads of around 1 pip on the EUR/USD but still trail the cheapest brokers like IC Markets, plus there's an inactivity fee after 12 months.
- XTB discontinued support for MT4, limiting traders to its proprietary platform, xStation, potentially deterring advanced day traders familiar with the MetaTrader suite.
Legal Context
In March 2018, the ESMA decided to ban the advertising and distribution of binary options to retail investors. It also restricted the advertising and sale of CFDs. These new changes came into force in July and August 2018. They were accompanied by transparency requirements such as the disclosure of the percentage of winning clients of each broker.
Profitable Traders – Long Term
These figures need to be updated every three months to comply with the regulator. But numbers can shift significantly.
Check out the brokers where the winning % stays high over the long term.
Volatile markets and specific events can also impact these numbers, so always use them to compare ‘like for like’ brokers, rather than from different periods.
A broker with a consistently high number of winning traders is clearly able to make a profit without compromising the trader – either by charging high fees or squeezing margins elsewhere.
It also suggests a brand that values their clients, which is always a positive.
Social Trading
Social trading (or copy trading) has impacted these figures. While some traders will doubtless lose money, they can re-enter the market and follow the trades of profitable traders, and thus get ‘in the black’ themselves.
Many of the brokers with higher figures for winning traders also operate social trading or copy trading schemes, and it is no coincidence.
Increased Transparency – Benefits?
Following these revelations, brokers will start using this number as a marketing device. In other words, retail investors will be more attracted by brokers with the highest percentage of winning accounts.
Therefore, trading platforms will start doing their best to increase this number, especially through the use of educational material and supplementary analytical tools. By providing traders with the necessary information to carry out profitable investments, brokers will be able to increase their percentage of winning accounts and attract more and more users. A win-win situation!