Which broker has the most profitable traders? Or as some like to put it – which brokers have the fewest losing traders? This is a question that most traders think about and yet seems unanswerable… How and why would brokers reveal this information?
Thanks to the ESMA (European Securities and Markets Authority), brokers are now bound to disclose their percentage of winning/losing traders. This increased transparency has the potential to disrupt the market for binary options, CFDs and forex. This article will explore these revelations and assess their impact on the future of retail trading.
Brokers With Most Winning Traders
These are the top 6 brokers with the most winning traders, and what percentage of their traders are profitable:
-
- Demo account
- Min. deposit: $10 (varies by account and payment method)
- Min. trade: 0.01 Lots
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: FCA, ASIC, JSC, FSC, VFSC, FSA
- Platforms: MT4, MT5, TradingCentral
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: FCA
- Platforms: MT4, MT5
-
- Demo account
- Min. deposit: $0
- Min. trade: 0.01 Lots
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: CySEC, FSCA, FSA, ADGM/FRSA
- Min. deposit: $10-$250 (location and tier dependent)
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: BVI FSC
- Platforms: MT4, MT5
Learn how we test brokers and why you can trust our ratings.
Here is a short overview of each broker's pros and cons
- Exness 4.1/5 Established in 2008, Exness has maintained its position as a highly respected broker, standing out with its industry-leading range of 40+ account currencies, growing selection of CFD instruments, and intuitive web platform complete with useful extras like currency convertors and trading calculators.
- Hantec Markets 3.8/5 Hantec Markets was established in Hong Kong in 1990. Initially, the company concentrated solely on the Chinese and Taiwanese markets. In 2008, the broker rebranded and expanded its presence in the UK, Australia, Japan, and various other countries, before enhancing its footprint in Latin America in 2022. Hantec now stands as a multinational brokerage with 18 offices across Europe and Asia.
- TIOmarkets 3.9/5 TIOmarkets is a global forex and CFD brokerage with both an offshore and UK-regulated branch. The broker has a strong customer focus, with 24/7 telephone and live chat customer service. Traders can access a range of accounts with competitive spreads from 0.4 pips.
- IG 4.8/5 Founded in 1974, IG is part of IG Group Holdings Plc, a publicly traded (LSE: IGG) brokerage. The brand offers a top-tier selection of 17,000+ markets, with a range of user-friendly platforms and investing apps. For 50 years, IG has maintained its position as an industry leader, excelling in all key areas for traders.
- NAGA 4.1/5 NAGA is a German-headquartered social investing platform offering copy trading on thousands of financial markets including CFDs and real stocks. Founded in 2015, the company is publicly listed on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange and regulated in the EU, Middle East and globally. The firm offers an all-in-one web platform and mobile app, but traders can also synchronize their NAGA accounts with popular third-party software, including MT4 and MT5.
- InstaForex 3.2/5 InstaForex is a CFD broker providing access to forex, stocks, cryptocurrencies, commodities, energies, indices, and more. With competitive fees and a huge range of available assets, the brand offers safe and reliable trading. Millions of traders have opened an account with the firm which offers a suite of active trading and investment opportunities.
Community Sentiment
See how users rate these brokers based on the average customer ratings submitted on DayTrading.com, plus ratings from Trustpilot, the Apple App Store and Google Play.
| Broker | Our Users' Rating | Trustpilot Score | Trustpilot Reviews | iOS App Rating | Android App Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exness | 33680 | ||||
| Hantec Markets | 5642 | ||||
| TIOmarkets | - | 733 | - | - | |
| IG | 10162 | ||||
| NAGA | - | 4121 | |||
| InstaForex | 553 |
Exness
After slashing its spreads, improving its execution speeds and support trading on over 100 currency pairs with more than 40 account currencies to choose from, Exness is a fantastic option for active forex traders looking to minimize trading costs.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
Exness quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs on Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, Crypto
- Regulator
- FSCA, CMA-Kenya, FSA, CBCS, BVIFSC, FSC, JSC, FCA (B2B only), CySEC (B2B only)
- Platforms
- Exness Trade App, Exness Terminal, MT4, MT5, TradingCentral
- Minimum Deposit
- $10 (varies by account and payment method)
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, NZD, INR, JPY, ZAR, MYR, IDR, CHF, HKD, SGD, AED, SAR, HUF, BRL, NGN, THB, VND, UAH, KWD, QAR, KRW, MXN, KES, CNY
Exness Profitable Traders
Pros
- Highly competitive spreads, reduced for USOIL and BTCUSD in 2024, are available from 0 pips with low commissions from $2 per side.
- Fast and dependable 24/7 multilingual customer support via telephone, email and live chat based on hands-on tests.
- Exness Terminal offers a streamlined experience for beginners with dynamic charts while setting up watchlists is a breeze.
Cons
- MetaTrader 4 and 5 are supported, but TradingView and cTrader still aren’t despite rising demand from active traders and integration at alternatives like Pepperstone.
- Apart from a mediocre blog, educational resources are woeful, especially compared to category leaders like IG which provide a more complete trading journey for newer traders.
- Exness has expanded its range of CFDs, but there are still no real assets such as ETFs, cryptocurrencies or bonds
Hantec Markets
Hantec Markets is suitable if you want a no-frills MetaTrader broker to trade CFDs on stocks, forex, indices, commodities and cryptos. However, the customer support and educational tools trail the best brokers.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
Hantec Markets quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- Forex, CFDs, Indices, Stocks, Commodities, Cryptos
- Regulator
- FCA, ASIC, JSC, FSC, VFSC, FSA
- Platforms
- MT4, MT5, TradingCentral
- Minimum Deposit
- $10
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, CHF, PLN, AED
Hantec Markets Profitable Traders
Pros
- The entry barrier for trading is notably low for beginners, starting from just $10, while deposits are fee-free and can be completed smoothly from the client area.
- Trading Central integration provides an excellent one-stop-shop for technical, fundamental, economic, sentiment and news analysis, helping users discover short-term trading opportunities.
- Hantec Markets is a trusted broker, with a track record stretching back to 1990 and authorization from ‘green tier’ regulators, notably the ASIC.
Cons
- Hantec Markets needs to bolster its investment offering to match category leaders like Blackbull Markets, especially in its breadth of currency pairs and commodities.
- There is no proprietary software aimed at newer traders, nor integration with the increasingly popular TradingView and cTrader platforms. Additionally MT5 is not available in certain regions.
- The educational tools, consisting primarily of long-form articles, need revamping with interactive elements and videos to match the training materials at IG.
TIOmarkets
TIOmarkets is best suited to experienced traders who can deposit at least $1000 to take advantage of the competitive trading conditions available with the VIP accounts. It also suits hands-off traders with copy trading and PAMM solutions.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
TIOmarkets quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- Forex, CFDs, indices, shares, commodities, cryptocurrencies
- Regulator
- FCA
- Platforms
- MT4, MT5
- Minimum Deposit
- $20
- Minimum Trade
- 0.001 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, ZAR, AED
TIOmarkets Profitable Traders
Pros
- Opening a Raw or VIP Black account doesn't mean starting over — it sits alongside your existing accounts under the same login, with funds and history intact. Brokers that treat each account type as a separate registration make scaling up unnecessarily cumbersome. TIOmarkets doesn't.
- Most brokers at TIOmarkets' level either skip PAMM entirely or offer a stripped-down version. Having both copy trading and a proper PAMM structure under the same roof gives skilled traders a genuine route to managing external capital — and gives passive investors access to verified managers — without needing a separate platform or provider.
- Many brokers that straddle regulated and offshore jurisdictions deliberately obscure which entity your account actually falls under. TIOmarkets keeps it clear: UK clients sit under the FCA-authorized arm, international clients go through the offshore entity, and there's no ambiguity about which protections apply to whom.
Cons
- At just over 300 instruments, TIOmarkets' offering looks thin next to brokers like IG or Saxo Bank, which list thousands of tradeable assets. Traders wanting genuine breadth across global equities, sector ETF CFDs, bonds, options, or niche commodity contracts will hit the ceiling quickly.
- Relatively shallow in-house research and analysis cover the basics, but there's no integration with Trading Central, Autochartist, or any other professional-grade third-party analysis provider. Many brokers bundle these tools in at no extra cost, giving their clients a genuine analytical edge that TIOmarkets' current research offering doesn't come close to matching.
- No proprietary platform means being locked into MT4 and MT5, so TIOmarkets has no ability to differentiate the actual trading experience. Top brokers offer TradingView and cTrader alongside MetaTrader, giving traders access to a far more intuitive, visually modern environment without sacrificing execution quality. For anyone who finds MetaTrader's interface dated, there's simply no alternative here.
IG
IG continues to provide a comprehensive package with an intuitive web platform, best-in-class education for beginners, advanced charting tools bolstered by its recent TradingView integration, real-time data, and robust trade execution for experienced day traders.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
IG quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs (not in US), Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, ETFs, Futures, Options, Crypto, Spread Betting (UK only)
- Regulator
- CFTC, NFA, FCA, BaFin, ASIC, FINMA, MAS, JFSA, FMA, DFSA, BMA, CONSOB
- Platforms
- Web, L2 Dealer, MT4, TradingView, AutoChartist, TradingCentral, ProRealTime
- Minimum Deposit
- $0
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, JPY, ZAR, SEK, DKK, CHF, HKD, SGD
IG Profitable Traders
Pros
- IG is amongst the best in terms of its range of instruments, which includes stocks, forex, indices, commodities, and cryptocurrencies, plus added US-listed futures and options as well as an AI Index, providing diversification opportunities.
- The IG app offers a superb mobile trading experience with a clean design that helped it secure Runner Up at our 'Best Trading App' award.
- IG obtained a crypto asset license from the FCA, allowing it to re-enter the UK market to provide buying, selling and storing opportunities on 55+ digital tokens with fees from 1.49%, and all within an FCA-licensed environment.
Cons
- Beginners might find IG’s fee structure complex, with various fees for different types of trades or services, potentially leading to confusion or unexpected charges.
- IG has discontinued its swap-free account, reducing its appeal to Islamic traders.
- IG applies an inactivity fee of $12-$18 per month after 2 years, deterring casual investors.
NAGA
NAGA is a snug fit for beginners who like to learn by watching others, delivering a more advanced social trading network than the majority of CFD brokers, featuring a leaderboard with top traders by profit and win rate, and a one-tap autocopy function in the platform and app that’s a standout.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
NAGA quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs on Forex, Indices, Shares, Commodities, Crypto, Real Stocks and Futures
- Regulator
- CySEC, FSCA, FSA, ADGM/FRSA
- Platforms
- NAGA Platform, NAGA App, MT4, MT5, TradingView, TradingCentral
- Minimum Deposit
- $10-$250 (location and tier dependent)
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, PLN
NAGA Profitable Traders
Pros
- NAGA Group AG, the parent company, is listed on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange and publishes audited financial statements. This level of transparency is not available with privately held offshore brokers.
- During testing, we were approved to begin trading very quickly; after we provided our ID and proof of address, approval was granted the next business day, and the onboarding process included a suitability questionnaire — a responsible step that some brokers fail to include.
- NAGA stands out among social brokers for its wide range of assets, offering over 4,000 tradable options. These include forex pairs, stock, ETF, and index CFDs, commodity CFDs, crypto, and even exchange-traded futures, which are rare for retail clients.
Cons
- NAGA’s pricing structure is tough on smaller accounts. There’s only one account type, but it has six tiers based on your deposit. The EUR/USD spread is about 1.7 pips at the Iron tier and drops to a competitive 0.9 pips at Diamond ($50,000 deposit) or 0.7 pips at Crystal ($100,000 deposit).
- The $50 monthly inactivity fee is on the high end of the scale. It kicks in after two months of no activity, not every quarter like some brokers. If your balance falls below $50 while your account is inactive, NAGA takes whatever is left and closes your account.
- The 1:30 leverage limit only applies to clients in the EU (under CySEC) and the GCC (through Abu Dhabi’s ADGM). Clients from LATAM, Asia, and Africa use the Seychelles or FSCA entities, where leverage can go up to 1:1000 and there’s no compensation scheme. This mix of high leverage and little protection is a risk, along with concerns about its suspended Trustpilot score in 2026.
InstaForex
InstaForex is a good choice for currency traders familiar with the MT4 and MT5 platforms. The broker offers more forex pairs than most rivals with very tight spreads and a low minimum deposit.
William Berg, Reviewer
InstaForex quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- Forex, shares, indices, metals, oil and gas, futures, cryptos, binary options
- Regulator
- BVI FSC
- Platforms
- MT4, MT5
- Minimum Deposit
- $1
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR
InstaForex Profitable Traders
Pros
- Wide market access with hundreds of assets
- Reputable brand that over seven million investors have signed up to in the last 15+ years
- Low minimum deposit to get started
Cons
- Mixed user reviews on third-party sites, including some complaints of withdrawal issues
- The broker’s website and Client Cabinet can feel tricky to navigate
Legal Context
In March 2018, the ESMA decided to ban the advertising and distribution of binary options to retail investors. It also restricted the advertising and sale of CFDs. These new changes came into force in July and August 2018. They were accompanied by transparency requirements such as the disclosure of the percentage of winning clients of each broker.
Profitable Traders – Long Term
These figures need to be updated every three months to comply with the regulator. But numbers can shift significantly.
Check out the brokers where the winning % stays high over the long term.
Volatile markets and specific events can also impact these numbers, so always use them to compare ‘like for like’ brokers, rather than from different periods.
A broker with a consistently high number of winning traders is clearly able to make a profit without compromising the trader – either by charging high fees or squeezing margins elsewhere.
It also suggests a brand that values their clients, which is always a positive.
Social Trading
Social trading (or copy trading) has impacted these figures. While some traders will doubtless lose money, they can re-enter the market and follow the trades of profitable traders, and thus get ‘in the black’ themselves.
Many of the brokers with higher figures for winning traders also operate social trading or copy trading schemes, and it is no coincidence.
Increased Transparency – Benefits?
Following these revelations, brokers will start using this number as a marketing device. In other words, retail investors will be more attracted by brokers with the highest percentage of winning accounts.
Therefore, trading platforms will start doing their best to increase this number, especially through the use of educational material and supplementary analytical tools. By providing traders with the necessary information to carry out profitable investments, brokers will be able to increase their percentage of winning accounts and attract more and more users. A win-win situation!