Which broker has the most profitable traders? Or as some like to put it – which brokers have the fewest losing traders? This is a question that most traders think about and yet seems unanswerable… How and why would brokers reveal this information?
Thanks to the ESMA (European Securities and Markets Authority), brokers are now bound to disclose their percentage of winning/losing traders. This increased transparency has the potential to disrupt the market for binary options, CFDs and forex. This article will explore these revelations and assess their impact on the future of retail trading.
Brokers With Most Winning Traders
These are the top 6 brokers with the most winning traders, and what percentage of their traders are profitable:
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: FCA, CySEC, FC
- Platforms: TickTrader, MT4, MT5, TradingView
-
- Demo account
- Min. deposit: $0
- Min. trade: 0.01 Lots
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: FCA, DFSA
- Platforms: HYCM Trader, MT4, MT5, TradingCentral
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: FCA, CySEC, FSCA, BVI FSC
- Platforms: MT4, MT5, AutoChartist, TradingCentral
-
- Demo account
- Instruments: Forex, CFDs, indices, shares, commodities
- Platforms: MT4
-
- Demo account
- Regulator: BVI FSC
- Platforms: MT4, MT5
Learn how we test brokers and why you can trust our ratings.
Here is a short overview of each broker's pros and cons
- FXOpen 3.7/5 Established in 2005, FXOpen is a multi-regulated broker that has attracted over 1 million traders. Designed for active trading, it provides access to a growing selection of more than 700 markets and supports high-frequency trading, scalping, and all forms of algorithmic trading using expert advisors (EAs).
- IG 4.8/5 Founded in 1974, IG is part of IG Group Holdings Plc, a publicly traded (LSE: IGG) brokerage. The brand offers a top-tier selection of 17,000+ markets, with a range of user-friendly platforms and investing apps. For 50 years, IG has maintained its position as an industry leader, excelling in all key areas for traders.
- HYCM 3.8/5 HYCM is an online broker with authorization from four international bodies including the FCA. The broker offers short-term CFD trading on forex, shares, commodities, indices, ETFs and Bitcoin, and supports the MT4 and MT5 platforms, as well as Trading Central analysis.
- IronFX 3.8/5 IronFX is a multi-regulated forex and CFD broker founded in 2010. This award-winning firm offers 500+ markets to over 1.5 million clients across 180 countries. Traders can access various account types with competitive pricing on the MT4 platform, as well as 24/5 customer support in 30 languages.
- LMFX 2.6/5 LMFX is an offshore CFD and forex broker with flexible account options that support trading with fixed or floating spreads, including a raw spread account with super tight pricing. The assets on offer include forex, stocks, indices and commodities, and very high leverage up to 1:1000 is available. The broker is based in Macedonia and was established in 2017.
- InstaForex 3.2/5 InstaForex is a CFD broker providing access to forex, stocks, cryptocurrencies, commodities, energies, indices, and more. With competitive fees and a huge range of available assets, the brand offers safe and reliable trading. Millions of traders have opened an account with the firm which offers a suite of active trading and investment opportunities.
Community Sentiment
See how users rate these brokers based on the average customer ratings submitted on DayTrading.com, plus ratings from Trustpilot, the Apple App Store and Google Play.
| Broker | Our Users' Rating | Trustpilot Score | Trustpilot Reviews | iOS App Rating | Android App Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FXOpen | 462 | ||||
| IG | 10162 | ||||
| HYCM | - | 139 | |||
| IronFX | 724 | ||||
| LMFX | - | - | |||
| InstaForex | 553 |
FXOpen
FXOpen is ideal for high-volume traders, offering fast execution through its ECN trading infrastructure, spreads from 0 pips, and discounted commissions as low as $1.50 per lot.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
FXOpen quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs, Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, Crypto, ETFs
- Regulator
- FCA, CySEC, FC
- Platforms
- TickTrader, MT4, MT5, TradingView
- Minimum Deposit
- $100
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, AUD, JPY, CHF, SGD, RUB
FXOpen Profitable Traders
Pros
- FXOpen reduced FX spreads by 40%+ in 2022 and introduced commission-free index trading in 2023, making it cost-effective for day traders.
- FXOpen streamlined its account offerings in 2024, ensuring a user-friendly setup with ECN accounts providing raw spreads from 0.0 pips, fast execution speeds, and discounted commissions for high-volume traders.
- FXOpen introduced TradingView in 2022 and upgraded its TickTrader platform in 2024, offering Level 2 pricing, 1,200+ trading tools, and advanced order types, catering to both experienced and high-frequency traders.
Cons
- Despite bolstering its asset range, FXOpen still offers fewer global stocks, commodities, and cryptocurrencies than category leader BlackBull, reducing access to diverse trading opportunities.
- FXOpen has a threadbare educational offering, lacking the courses and webinars you can find at brokers like IG, limiting its appeal to beginners seeking to build their knowledge.
- While still a trusted broker with authorization from the FCA and CySEC, FXOpen lost its ASIC license in 2024 following ‘serious concerns’ and no longer onboards Australian traders.
IG
IG continues to provide a comprehensive package with an intuitive web platform, best-in-class education for beginners, advanced charting tools bolstered by its recent TradingView integration, real-time data, and robust trade execution for experienced day traders.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
IG quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs (not in US), Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, ETFs, Futures, Options, Crypto, Spread Betting (UK only)
- Regulator
- CFTC, NFA, FCA, BaFin, ASIC, FINMA, MAS, JFSA, FMA, DFSA, BMA, CONSOB
- Platforms
- Web, L2 Dealer, MT4, TradingView, AutoChartist, TradingCentral, ProRealTime
- Minimum Deposit
- $0
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, JPY, ZAR, SEK, DKK, CHF, HKD, SGD
IG Profitable Traders
Pros
- The proprietary web-based platform continues to caters to traders of all levels, with advanced charting tools and real-time market data useful for day trading, while IG has also added TradingView integration.
- As a well-established broker, IG operates under strict regulatory guidelines in multiple jurisdictions, maintaining a high level of trust.
- IG is amongst the best in terms of its range of instruments, which includes stocks, forex, indices, commodities, and cryptocurrencies, plus added US-listed futures and options as well as an AI Index, providing diversification opportunities.
Cons
- IG applies an inactivity fee of $12-$18 per month after 2 years, deterring casual investors.
- IG has discontinued its swap-free account, reducing its appeal to Islamic traders.
- Beginners might find IG’s fee structure complex, with various fees for different types of trades or services, potentially leading to confusion or unexpected charges.
HYCM
Traders looking for a multi-asset broker with good platform support, extra analysis features and strong regulation will want to consider HYCM. The competitive raw-spread accounts will also serve scalpers and high-volume traders.
Christian Harris, Reviewer
HYCM quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- CFDs, Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, ETFs
- Regulator
- FCA, DFSA
- Platforms
- HYCM Trader, MT4, MT5, TradingCentral
- Minimum Deposit
- $20
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, RUB, AED
HYCM Profitable Traders
Pros
- Most retail CFD brokers stop at gold, oil, and silver. HYCM extends into agricultural soft commodities from a standard account with no elevated minimum deposit or professional classification required. For traders wanting genuine commodity diversification beyond metals and energy, that access is structurally rare at this entry level.
- Rather than a flat leverage cap, HYCM's leverage model reduces automatically as position volume increases — protecting traders from runaway exposure on large positions without requiring manual margin management. Most retail brokers apply a fixed leverage ceiling and leave risk management entirely to the trader. The dynamic model adds a structural risk layer that's particularly relevant for less experienced traders building larger positions incrementally.
- HYCM has operated continuously since 1977 — through Black Wednesday, the 2008 financial crisis, the SNB shock, and multiple FCA overhauls that eliminated or restructured many competitors. Most brokers marketing FCA regulation acquired it recently. HYCM has held it long enough for an entire generation of retail traders to have come and gone. That's a verifiably different category of track record.
Cons
- Brokers like eToro, Pepperstone, and IC Markets have built entire client acquisition channels around social and copy trading. HYCM has none of it. For newer traders who want to allocate capital to experienced strategies while they develop their own, or for experienced traders who want to monetize their track record by managing external capital, HYCM offers no pathway. That's an entire category of retail trader HYCM cannot serve.
- MT4, MT5, and a proprietary mobile app are the same infrastructure HYCM offered half a decade ago. No TradingView integration, no cTrader, no social trading, no copy trading, no PAMM. For a broker with nearly five decades of history and FCA authorization, the absence of any platform development signals that technology investment isn't a priority, which matters increasingly as competitors bundle TradingView natively and build out social trading ecosystems that attract a new generation of retail traders.
- The restriction only surfaces in HYCM's terms and conditions. Traders who fund a Fixed or Classic account, develop a short-term strategy, and start executing fast in-and-out trades can have their profits confiscated and their accounts suspended without prior warning. The Raw account permits tighter execution styles, but the policy boundary between permitted and prohibited trading frequency is never clearly defined in plain language anywhere on hycm.com.
IronFX
IronFX remains a good choice for experienced forex traders looking to trade with fixed or floating spreads. The range of 80+ currencies is more than many competitors and there are some excellent forex market research tools on offer.
Tobias Robinson, Reviewer
IronFX quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- Forex, Indices, Shares, Futures, Commodities, Metals (all CFDs)
- Regulator
- FCA, CySEC, FSCA, BVI FSC
- Platforms
- MT4, MT5, AutoChartist, TradingCentral
- Minimum Deposit
- $100
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR, GBP, AUD, JPY, PLN, CZK
IronFX Profitable Traders
Pros
- Traders get access to the popular Trading Central research tool, which offers automated AI analytics and 24/7 support
- Alongside MT4, the broker continues to offer several additional services, including copy trading, a VPS solution, and PAMM/MAM accounts
- Fixed and floating spread accounts are available, making IronFX a good choice for both beginners and experienced traders
Cons
- The offshore BVI entity brings with it lower regulator mandated safeguards and oversight
- Compared to the leading brokers, IronFX offers a relatively small selection of share CFDs
- Commissions start from $13.50 per lot in the zero-spread accounts, nearly double the industry average
LMFX
Experienced traders who want highly leveraged CFDs and a choice between fixed and floating spreads should consider LMFX. On the downside, new clients should note the weak regulatory oversight.
William Berg, Reviewer
LMFX quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- Forex, CFDs, indices, shares, commodities
- Platforms
- MT4
- Minimum Deposit
- $5
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR
LMFX Profitable Traders
Pros
- Zero deposit fees
- Excellent, flexible pricing options with raw and fixed spreads available
- LMFX has cut its minimum deposit from $50 to $5, making it more accessible
Cons
- Limited educational resources for newer traders
- Unregulated status lowers its safety score
- No cryptocurrency and Bitcoin trading
InstaForex
InstaForex is a good choice for currency traders familiar with the MT4 and MT5 platforms. The broker offers more forex pairs than most rivals with very tight spreads and a low minimum deposit.
William Berg, Reviewer
InstaForex quick facts
- Demo Account
- ✔Yes
- Instruments
- Forex, shares, indices, metals, oil and gas, futures, cryptos, binary options
- Regulator
- BVI FSC
- Platforms
- MT4, MT5
- Minimum Deposit
- $1
- Minimum Trade
- 0.01 Lots
- Account Currencies
- USD, EUR
InstaForex Profitable Traders
Pros
- MT4 and MT5 integration
- Low minimum deposit to get started
- Wide market access with hundreds of assets
Cons
- Mixed user reviews on third-party sites, including some complaints of withdrawal issues
- The broker’s website and Client Cabinet can feel tricky to navigate
Legal Context
In March 2018, the ESMA decided to ban the advertising and distribution of binary options to retail investors. It also restricted the advertising and sale of CFDs. These new changes came into force in July and August 2018. They were accompanied by transparency requirements such as the disclosure of the percentage of winning clients of each broker.
Profitable Traders – Long Term
These figures need to be updated every three months to comply with the regulator. But numbers can shift significantly.
Check out the brokers where the winning % stays high over the long term.
Volatile markets and specific events can also impact these numbers, so always use them to compare ‘like for like’ brokers, rather than from different periods.
A broker with a consistently high number of winning traders is clearly able to make a profit without compromising the trader – either by charging high fees or squeezing margins elsewhere.
It also suggests a brand that values their clients, which is always a positive.
Social Trading
Social trading (or copy trading) has impacted these figures. While some traders will doubtless lose money, they can re-enter the market and follow the trades of profitable traders, and thus get ‘in the black’ themselves.
Many of the brokers with higher figures for winning traders also operate social trading or copy trading schemes, and it is no coincidence.
Increased Transparency – Benefits?
Following these revelations, brokers will start using this number as a marketing device. In other words, retail investors will be more attracted by brokers with the highest percentage of winning accounts.
Therefore, trading platforms will start doing their best to increase this number, especially through the use of educational material and supplementary analytical tools. By providing traders with the necessary information to carry out profitable investments, brokers will be able to increase their percentage of winning accounts and attract more and more users. A win-win situation!