Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity

Contributor Image
Written By
Contributor Image
Written By
Dan Buckley
Dan Buckley is an US-based trader, consultant, and part-time writer with a background in macroeconomics and mathematical finance. He trades and writes about a variety of asset classes, including equities, fixed income, commodities, currencies, and interest rates. As a writer, his goal is to explain trading and finance concepts in levels of detail that could appeal to a range of audiences, from novice traders to those with more experienced backgrounds.

A hedge fund and private equity firm both serve a similar purpose in that they both seek to generate returns on investment.

However, there are key differences between the two. Hedge funds typically use more aggressive strategies involving liquid investments relative to private equity firms, which focus on illiquid investments.

Hedge funds are typically open-ended investments and employ a wide range of strategies including long/short equity, arbitrage, derivatives, and relative value trades.

Private equity firms usually have a longer-term horizon and make larger capital commitments to companies through buyouts or investing in startups as venture capitalists do.

They often focus on taking over existing businesses or providing growth capital to promising startups.

When evaluating which is right for your portfolio, it’s important to understand the nature of each strategy and its objectives.


Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity – Key Takeaways

  • Hedge funds are generally more liquid than private equity investments, meaning investors can withdraw their money more easily from a hedge fund (though it’s generally only partially liquid, such as pulling out 1/8 of their investment once per quarter, though it depends on the terms of the contract).
  • Private equity investment typically require longer-term commitments than hedge funds (often 5-10-year lockup periods).
  • Hedge funds tend to be more actively managed and can use more sophisticated strategies than those available to private equity firms because of the liquid nature of many of their positions.
  • Hedge funds focus on shorter-term gains derived from market movements and arbitrage opportunities, while private equity firms focus on long-term growth through strategic investments in companies and operations management.
  • Hedge funds may also employ leverage, or borrowed capital, to amplify returns while private equity firms generally rely on borrowed debt to increase returns on equity.


Hedge Funds

Hedge funds are typically absolute return investment vehicles, meaning that they have a goal of generating positive returns regardless of the direction of the broader market.

They often employ leverage, derivatives, and short selling in order to achieve this.

Hedge funds are typically less liquid than other investment vehicles and can be more costly due to high management fees.


Private Equity

Private equity firms, on the other hand, focus more on long-term investments in companies with growth potential.

They look for companies that have solid fundamentals (e.g., profits or positive EBITDA, clean balance sheets) but may lack capital or strategic planning to realize their full potential.

Rather than taking a passive approach as some investment managers do, private equity actively works to increase the value of the company through operational improvements, additional capital investments, or changes in management team leadership.

Private equity typically requires a longer-term commitment than hedge funds and can be costly due to high fees and the illiquidity of the investment.


Activist Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity – What’s the Difference?

An activist hedge fund might seem similar to private equity.

Both are concerned with improving the operations of a business in some way, as that’s their value-add to markets.

However, activist hedge funds generally take a more active and public approach than private equity.

Activist hedge funds use their financial resources to buy up large stakes in companies that they believe are undervalued and then engage publicly with management to push for changes (e.g., get representation on the board of directors).

Private equity is hands-on operationally, often setting up offices inside the company that they invest in and working closely with the management team (even instituting their own management team) to develop strategies for growth.

Both strategies can be effective in generating returns but investors should consider their own risk tolerance when deciding which is best suited for them.


Hedge Funds vs. Mutual Funds vs. Private Equity

Hedge funds, mutual funds, and private equity are all different types of investment vehicles that corporations, institutions, high net worth individuals, and, in the case of mutual funds, non-accredited investors can use to invest their money.

Hedge funds are typically used as a way to manage risk in an investment portfolio, while mutual funds are a more general investment option for those looking for broad diversification without the need for complex strategies.

Private equity is used by firms or groups of investors to purchase businesses or portions of businesses with the goal of increasing their value over time.

Private equity may have higher returns than standard public equity investing because the returns are aided via leverage – which, in turn, makes them riskier – and they may be able to better identify investments that haven’t been combed over like those available on public exchanges.


Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity vs. Venture Capital

Hedge funds often employ sophisticated strategies such as short selling, leveraging, derivatives, and other tactics to generate higher returns than traditional long-term investments.

The downside is that hedge funds tend to be much more expensive due to their complex nature and higher risk.

Private equity firms typically purchase companies or parts of companies with the goal of increasing the value of these investments over time, usually by restructuring operations and then selling them to generate profits. Private equity is a longer-term investment with higher potential returns but also higher risks.

PE returns are often increased by buying most of the company with debt, then using the company’s cash flows to pay down the debt. This helps leverage returns higher since less equity is committed.

Venture capital invests in private companies at an early stage of development with the objective of generating high returns on their investments.

Venture capitalists take more risks than private equity firms since they are investing in unproven businesses and technologies, so they tend to seek larger returns than other types of investors.


Hedge fund vs. private equity vs. investment banking – What’s the difference?

Hedge funds, private equity, and investment banking are three distinct segments of the financial services industry that all provide investment capital to companies.

Each has its own unique set of characteristics, goals, and approaches.

Hedge funds are private funds that employ sophisticated strategies such as derivatives, leverage, and short selling in order to generate high returns for their investors.

Hedge fund managers have considerable flexibility to pursue their chosen strategies, making them attractive investments for some investors.

However, they also come with a higher degree of risk since they are not regulated by the SEC or other regulatory bodies like mutual funds.

Private equity firms purchase a majority stake in companies and then attempt to increase their market value over time through strategic management changes and corporate restructuring.

Private equity investments are typically long-term and carry a high risk of loss.

Investment banking is the process of providing advisory and capital raising services to companies and other entities. Investment banks can help companies raise funds through stock issuances, mergers and acquisitions, underwriting debt securities, and assisting with corporate restructurings.

Investment bankers also provide research and advice to their clients on potential investments or acquisitions. Unlike hedge funds or private equity firms, investment banks do not necessarily directly invest in the companies they advise.

Hedge funds, private equity firms, and investment banks all serve important roles in capital markets by providing different types of financing solutions to corporations.


Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity Pay

The categories are so diverse that hedge funds or private equity generally don’t have a de facto pay edge.

Private equity, however, is generally more available to younger employees. It’s not uncommon to get private equity jobs right out of college or after two years of investment banking.

Hedge fund jobs, on the other hand, tend to be more scarce for younger financial professionals. As a result, those who do make it into the hedge fund industry typically have more experience and expertise.

In terms of actual compensation, salary and bonuses in each asset class can vary significantly depending on the company and specific job.

Hedge funds also tend to incorporate performance-based incentives in their pay structure, so that higher-performing employees can earn significantly more than average performers.

Overall, the type of work an individual does is often more important than the type of firm he or she works for when it comes to pay.

There are high-paid professionals in both private equity and hedge funds, but the key to maximizing compensation lies in finding a role where you can excel and get promoted quickly while still enjoying your job.

Ultimately, the best path to success is to find a job that you are passionate about and excel at it. With hard work and dedication, financial professionals in both private equity and hedge funds can achieve great success and attract top-tier pay packages.


Buy Side Compensation Explained! (Salary + Bonuses for Hedge Funds, Private Equity, Venture Capital)


FAQs – Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity

What is better hedge funds or private equity?

Ultimately, that depends on the individual investor’s goals and risk tolerance.

Hedge funds may be better for investors seeking higher returns with a higher degree of risk. Private equity is best suited for long-term investments. Investment banking may be most beneficial to companies in need of capital raising services or strategic advice.

No matter which option is chosen, it is important to understand the different investment options available and carefully weigh the risks and benefits before making any investments.

With careful consideration, investors are sure to find an investment option that fits their individual needs and objectives.

Which is riskier private equity or hedge funds?

It depends, as both may come with a certain degree of risk.

Private equity investments are typically long-term and carry a high risk of loss (often due to the use of leverage and not being able to pay off debt in the event something goes wrong), while hedge funds can offer investors higher returns but also come with a greater degree of risk since they are not regulated by the SEC or other regulatory bodies like mutual funds.

Ultimately, an investor’s individual risk tolerance, needs, and objectives are the biggest factors in determining which type of investment(s) is/are best suited for them.

Which offers more potential return: private equity or hedge funds?

Again, this depends on the individual investor’s goals and risk tolerance.

Hedge funds may offer higher returns for investors willing to accept a greater degree of risk.

Private equity investments, on the other hand, are typically long-term, illiquid, and leveraged.

Neither private equity nor hedge funds are guaranteed to produce a profit, so investors should carefully evaluate their risk tolerance and goals before making any investment decision.


Conclusion – Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity

The choice between investing in a hedge fund or private equity depends on your options and your individual risk tolerance and financial goals.

Hedge funds have more of a short-term focus overall (because of the liquid nature of their investments) while private equity has more of a long-term focus (lock-up periods are often 5-10 years). Both offer potential rewards, but they come with different levels of risks and costs.

The primary difference between hedge funds and private equity lies in their respective strategies. Hedge fund managers employ sophisticated strategies such as derivatives, leverage and short selling to generate high returns for their investors.

Private equity firms purchase a majority stake in companies and then attempt to increase their market value over time through strategic management changes and corporate restructuring.

It is important to understand the strategies employed by each type of firm before making an investment decision, as well as their objectives, fees, and liquidity policies. Doing so can help you make an informed decision that meets your needs and goals.

While there is no distinct advantage of hedge funds or private equity when it comes to pay, each offers unique opportunities for those willing to work hard enough to capitalize on them.

By understanding the differences between these two industries, you can better determine which career choice will offer the greatest potential for you personally.