Alternative Trading System (ATS)

Contributor Image
Written By
Contributor Image
Written By
Dan Buckley
Dan Buckley is an US-based trader, consultant, and part-time writer with a background in macroeconomics and mathematical finance. He trades and writes about a variety of asset classes, including equities, fixed income, commodities, currencies, and interest rates. As a writer, his goal is to explain trading and finance concepts in levels of detail that could appeal to a range of audiences, from novice traders to those with more experienced backgrounds.

Alternative Trading Systems (ATS) are reshaping modern financial trading by offering competitive advantages over traditional exchanges.

They offer value-add to markets through lower fees, technological innovation, and specialized services tailored to specific trading strategies.

At the same time, ATSs also introduce challenges such as market fragmentation and regulatory complexities.


Key Takeaways – Alternative Trading System (ATS)

  • Cost Efficiency
    • ATS often reduce trading costs due to lower regulatory burdens.
    • Competitive fee structures are beneficial for traders.
  • Innovative Trading Solutions
    • They provide cutting-edge technologies and customized trading options.
    • Allows for sophisticated strategies and faster execution.
  • Privacy and Market Impact
    • ATS, especially dark pools, offer anonymity, and reduce the market impact for large transactions, which is important for institutional investors.


What Exactly is an Alternative Trading System?

An ATS is a trading venue that matches buyers and sellers of securities outside of traditional stock exchanges. 

Unlike public exchanges, ATSs are not regulated as exchanges.

They’re instead overseen as broker-dealers.

This allows for greater flexibility in operation and less stringent disclosure requirements. 

They provide a platform for trading a wide range of financial instruments.

They often focus on specific niche markets (e.g., commercial real estate investments for retail traders/investors) or offering innovative trading technologies and services.


The Role of ATS in Modern Trading

Here’s how they’re changing the game:


ATSs push traditional exchanges to innovate and lower fees.


They offer specialized platforms and order types that cater to specific trading strategies.


While it can be a downside, it also creates opportunities for niche players and fosters innovation.

More venues mean more choices for traders.

Technological Advancements

ATSs are often the testing ground for new trading technologies.

They push the boundaries and drive the industry forward.


Benefits of Using an Alternative Trading System


First, ATSs often offer better prices than traditional exchanges.

This is because they’re not bound by the same regulations, so they can experiment with different fee structures and pricing models.

This competition drives down costs and can put more money in your pocket.


ATSs aren’t tied to the rules of traditional exchanges.

They can offer customized order types and trading algorithms that cater to your specific needs.

It’s like having a trading platform built just for you.


ATSs are often technologically innovative, implementing new systems that execute trades faster.

This can be a huge advantage for certain trading styles.


Some ATSs operate as “dark pools,” where your trades are hidden from the public eye.

This can be beneficial for large institutional investors who don’t want to tip off the market about their moves.

Unique Liquidity Pools

Lastly, ATSs can offer access to unique liquidity pools.

They might aggregate orders from multiple sources or provide access to specialized markets that aren’t available on traditional exchanges.

This can open up new trading opportunities and potentially improve your execution.


ATSs have downsides too, like less regulatory oversight and potential transparency issues.

But for many traders, the benefits can outweigh the risks.

So, if you’re looking for better prices, flexibility, speed, anonymity, and unique liquidity, an ATS might be just what you need.

But, do your homework and choose a reputable platform with a proven track record.


Regulatory Framework Governing ATS

ATSs are regulated differently than traditional exchanges.

While they still fall under the eye of the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) in the US, they have more flexibility.

This translates to a few key benefits for traders:

Reduced Compliance Costs

Less stringent regulations mean lower operating costs for ATSs.

These savings often get passed down to you in the form of lower fees.

Innovation Friendly

The relaxed regulatory environment allows ATSs to be more nimble and innovative.

They can quickly adapt to changing market needs.

This can give you access to new tools and platforms that traditional exchanges might not offer.

Tailored Solutions

ATSs can create custom-made trading solutions for specific types of traders or asset classes.

This means you can find a platform that perfectly matches your trading style and objectives.

Increased Competition

The rise of ATSs has injected some healthy competition into trading.

This pushes all venues to improve their offerings, leading to better prices, faster execution, and more transparency.


Nonetheless, less regulation also comes with potential risks.

There’s less oversight and trader protection compared to traditional exchanges.

So, it’s important to choose a reputable ATS with a strong track record and risk management practices.


Challenges and Limitations of ATS


Transparency can be an issue.

Some ATSs operate as “dark pools,” where trades happen in the shadows.

This lack of visibility raises concerns about fairness and potential for manipulation, especially for those not in the know.


Next, regulatory oversight is lighter for ATSs compared to traditional exchanges.

This might sound appealing, but it means less protection for investors.

If things go wrong, you might not have the same safeguards in place.


Then, there’s fragmentation.

With so many ATSs popping up, liquidity gets spread out.

This can make it harder to find the best prices for your trades, especially for less liquid securities.


Technological advances can be a double-edged sword.

ATSs often rely on complex algorithms and systems.

This can lead to faster execution and innovative features, but it also means potential for technical glitches and vulnerabilities.

Lack of availability during market hours becomes more common.


Access isn’t always easy.

Some ATSs cater to specific types of traders or require high minimums to participate.

This can create barriers for smaller players and limit access to certain markets.

So, while ATSs offer some enticing benefits, it’s important to weigh those against the potential challenges. Do your research, understand the risks, and choose a platform that aligns with your trading goals and risk tolerance.


Comparing ATS with Traditional Exchanges


Traditional exchanges are heavily regulated, while ATSs have more flexibility.

This means ATSs can innovate faster and offer unique features like customized order types or dark pools.

Traditional exchanges are playing catch-up, but they’re still the gold standard for transparency and trader/investor protection.


ATSs often have the edge here, thanks to their technology and streamlined processes.

But traditional exchanges are constantly upgrading their systems to keep pace.


ATSs can sometimes offer lower fees due to their less stringent regulations and operational efficiencies.

Nevertheless, traditional exchanges often have larger volumes, which can lead to tighter spreads and better overall execution for some trades.


Traditional exchanges are open to the public, while some ATSs cater to specific types of traders/investors or require high minimums.

So, if you’re an individual trader, your options might be limited with certain ATSs.

Market Impact

Large trades can move markets, and ATSs, especially dark pools, can help minimize this impact by keeping orders hidden.

Traditional exchanges, on the other hand, provide full transparency, which is essential for price discovery and fair markets.

Table: Alternative Trading Systems (ATS) vs. Traditional Exchanges

Here’s a comparative table outlining key differences between Alternative Trading Systems and traditional exchanges across various criteria:

Criteria Alternative Trading Systems (ATS) Traditional Exchanges
Regulation Generally subject to lighter regulatory requirements Heavily regulated to ensure market integrity
Transparency Often operate with less transparency (e.g., dark pools) High transparency, with visible order books
Technology and Innovation Typically more flexible, adopting new technologies quickly May be slower to adopt new technologies due to size and regulatory constraints
Access and Participation Limited to institutional investors or by membership Open to all types of investors
Market Impact Lower market impact for large trades due to confidentiality Large trades may influence market prices
Liquidity Can be lower compared to traditional exchanges Generally offers higher liquidity
Types of Assets Traded May specialize in niche markets or asset classes Broad range of asset classes
Cost and Fees Can offer lower costs due to reduced overhead and regulation Typically involve higher fees due to operational and regulatory costs
Operational Hours May offer extended or flexible trading hours Standardized trading hours


Overall, ATS offer advantages like innovation and confidentiality while also facing challenges like lower liquidity and restricted access.